Cat Scratching Post Comparison: PA 4005 vs PA 5650
By Ferplast U.K. | Published: 2026-10-28
Category: Comparisons
Compare Ferplast cat scratchers: the playful PA 4005 with a sisal post and the budget-friendly, double-faced PA 5650. Find the right fit for your cat and home.
Quick Answer
For a single, engaging scratching spot with a sisal post, choose the PA 4005. If you need a budget-friendly, versatile scratcher that can lie flat or stand, the PA 5650 is the better pick.
Scratching Surface: Sisal vs Carpet and Cardboard
The PA 4005 features a post wrapped in sisal fibre, a texture many cats love for a satisfying scratch. The PA 5650 offers two surfaces: one side carpet, the other sturdy cardboard. This gives you options to see what your cat prefers, but the PA 4005 provides a dedicated vertical scratching surface that can help protect furniture more effectively.
Design and Engagement
The PA 4005 is designed to capture attention with a friendly, smiley mouse or monkey face on top of the post, adding a playful touch to your home. The PA 5650 is a more utilitarian, double-faced scratcher available in two sizes. If your cat is motivated by toys and visual interest, the PA 4005 may encourage more use.
Price and Value
The PA 5650 is significantly more affordable, making it a low-cost way to test if a scratcher will be used. The PA 4005 is a higher investment but offers a more substantial, feature-rich scratching post that may last longer and provide more engagement for your cat.
Trade-Offs at a Glance
- Scratching Surface: PA 4005 offers a sisal post; PA 5650 offers carpet and cardboard. Sisal is a classic choice for nail care, while carpet and cardboard give variety.
- Design: PA 4005 has a playful face for engagement; PA 5650 is more basic but functional. If your cat needs visual stimulation, the PA 4005 may be more effective. Consider your cat's playfulness when choosing.
- Price: PA 5650 is much more affordable, making it a low-risk trial. PA 4005 costs more but offers a more substantial scratching post. If budget is tight, start with the PA 5650.
Product Facts
- Scratching post PA 4005: This scratching post has a comfy base covered with imitation fur and a post in sisal fibre, topped with a friendly mouse or monkey face. The sisal post gives your cat a satisfying vertical scratch, while the playful top adds visual appeal that can draw your cat to use it.
Scratching post PA 4005 - Scratching post PA 5650: This double-faced scratcher is lined with carpet on one side and sturdy cardboard on the other, and is available in Small and Medium sizes. You can offer two textures in one affordable product, letting you see which surface your cat prefers without a big commitment.
Scratching post PA 5650
Which One Fits Your Cat?
Best for
- Cats that enjoy vertical scratching and playful design – choose the PA 4005.
- Budget-conscious owners or multi-cat households wanting a low-cost trial – choose the PA 5650.
Not for
- Cats that only scratch on tall, sturdy posts – the PA 5650 may be too lightweight; consider a taller, more robust scratching post.
